wausfpp.org


Miller, April 12 2004

Text Source

Miller, Hagen S. "Equal in death" (Letter to the Editor in Opinion). Lawrence Journal-World (Lawrence, KS: Lawrence Journal-World; http://www.ljworld.com. April 12 2004): http://www.ljworld.com/section/archive/story/167044.


Message Unit 1 - an example of patriotized history

US troops are attacking.


The US did not go to Iraq to protect any US citizens.


Iraq was not trying to harm US citizens.

US troops are defending.

text:

... it is a soldier's job to fight and defend ...

Message Unit 2 - an example of patriotized history

US troops are breaking the law.


The US soldiers who went to Iraq in 2003 were breaking both US and international law. US troops had sworn to uphold the US constitution, but the attack on Iraq violated the US constitution. The conquest of Iraq violated the UN Charter, which forbids attacking another country without Security Council authorization "except in self-defence if an armed attack occurs", and which guarantees the sovereignty of every country, thus forbidding the creation of unsovereign states, such as the one that the US created in Iraq. The US Constitution says that any treaty to which the US is party is the supreme law of the land. During the conquest of Iraq, the US itself listed the UN Charter as a treaty to which it is party.

US troops are fulfilling the law.

text:

... I fully understand their duty and full weight of the pressure on their shoulders.

Message Unit 3 - an example of patriotized morality

Not taking care to avoid the appearance of saying something against US troops.
Taking great care to avoid being accused of saying anything against the troops.

text:

As a former military man, I fully understand ...

...

I am not in any way suggesting that the fact that they volunteered to perform that duty diminishes the value of their lives.